Back to Offshore & Investigations

The Greensill audit: signed in 2020, sanctioned in 2026

The FRC has sanctioned Saffery LLP and Michael Di Leto over the FY2019 Greensill Capital (UK) audit, more than six years after the opinion was signed. The FRC's decision identifies gaps in audit planning, evidence and quality control.

Listen to this article

29 paragraphs

Charles Pycraft · November 2026 · London

Cover card: The Greensill audit. Navy typographic ground with a gold frame and a small CP mark. By Charles Pycraft

Public record, with a short note on what firms can do now.

The short version

On 16 November 2026 the Financial Reporting Council published sanctions against Saffery LLP and audit engagement partner Michael Di Leto over the statutory audit of Greensill Capital (UK) Limited for the year ended 31 December 2019. The FRC's Final Settlement Decision Notice, dated 24 August 2026, records that the FY2019 financial statements were signed on 22 May 2020, and that Mr Di Leto signed an unmodified audit opinion on behalf of Saffery on 26 May 2020.

The FRC announced its investigation in June 2021. More than five years passed before it published the outcome. The case shows why the audit file matters when the work comes under scrutiny.

What the FRC imposed

The notice was issued under the Audit Enforcement Procedure. Saffery and Mr Di Leto admitted 23 breaches of Relevant Requirements on the FY2019 audit.

The sanctions on Saffery, as set out in the FRC's press notice and the FSDN, are a financial sanction of £581,250, discounted from £750,000 by 22.5% for admissions and early disposal; a published statement in the form of a severe reprimand; a declaration that the 2019 audit report signed on behalf of Saffery LLP did not satisfy the Relevant Requirements; and an order to take action to reduce the likelihood of recurrence of the breaches. The sanctions on Mr Di Leto are a financial sanction of £124,000, discounted from £160,000 by 22.5% for the same reason; a published statement in the form of a severe reprimand; and an order to take action to reduce the likelihood of recurrence.

The two financial sanctions come to £705,250. The press notice said the respondents were also ordered to pay Executive Counsel's investigation costs, without stating the amount. The FSDN does: £1,520,895.48, no later than 28 days after the date of the notice. That costs figure is more than twice the combined financial sanctions.

The 22.5% reduction was, the FSDN says, for admissions made before the conclusion of Stage (1) of the case. A Proposed Settlement Decision Notice was issued on 30 July 2026 and agreed the same day. An Independent Reviewer approved the final notice on 13 August 2026. The respondents co-operated with Executive Counsel's investigation, the press notice says, but the FSDN records that Executive Counsel did not treat that co-operation as exceptional and made no further discount on that ground.

What was admitted

The press notice lists the 23 admitted breaches as concerning planning and risk assessments; audit work on accounting policies, revenue, expected credit loss and going concern; the review of audit evidence; the operation of audit quality control; and the exercise of professional scepticism. "Overall, the breaches were serious and pervasive throughout the FY2019 audit," it says. The FRC found that the audit failed to respond properly to risks of material misstatement arising from revenue recognition, possible management override of controls, and the valuation and recovery of assets. It also found flaws in the audit of management's use of the going concern basis of accounting. "The lack of an appropriate audit response was underpinned by a failure to properly understand GCUK's business model and the risks that arose from it, and a lack of professional scepticism."

The FSDN is blunter. It says the audit work was "inadequate in numerous respects" and "often superficial." At paragraph 13 it states: "The FY2019 Audit was accordingly not fit for purpose in terms of adequately reducing the risk of material misstatement in the FY2019 Financial Statements to an acceptably low level." Simon Broadhurst, Deputy Executive Counsel, said the audit "failed to fully identify those risks, or to respond appropriately to the risks that were identified, including those relating to the fundamental question of GCUK's ability to continue as a going concern." The FSDN also records, as Adverse Finding 1, that the respondents initially assessed the audit as involving a "high" inherent risk, which under Saffery's own policies meant an Engagement Quality Control Reviewer should have been appointed. None was.

Two points set the limits of what has been found. First, the findings are about the quality of the audit work, as the FRC describes it. Paragraph 525 of the FSDN states that the breaches "were not intentional or deliberate, reckless or dishonest," related to only one audit year, and did not involve financial gain beyond the audit fee, which the notice records as £230,000. Neither Saffery nor Mr Di Leto has any disciplinary history with the FRC or the ICAEW, the notice also records.

Second, on the going concern failings, Executive Counsel "does not suggest that such breaches caused the Administration of GCUK," the FSDN states at paragraph 526. The press notice describes GCUK as the primary trading entity for the Greensill Group, an Australian-headquartered financial services group, supplying various forms of working capital finance. After difficulties in securing renewal of trade credit insurance, it ceased writing new business on 2 March 2021 and entered administration on 8 March 2021. The administration remains ongoing. The FSDN calls the failure to renew, or obtain alternative, trade credit insurance a key factor in that administration. Saffery had been the statutory auditor from August 2015 until administration, with Mr Di Leto as engagement partner throughout.

The FRC records that Saffery has changed and improved its audit processes since the FY2019 audit and that Mr Di Leto has taken remedial steps. At the time of the decision, the effectiveness of those measures had yet to be assessed. The remedial orders provide for reviews covering both the firm and the partner. Accountancy Age reported a joint statement from Darren Drake, managing partner at Saffery, and Kenneth McDowell, national audit partner at Saffery Audit UK: "We acknowledge and regret that certain areas of the 2019 audit of Greensill Capital (UK) fell short of the standards that we, and the market, expect." They added that they have "drawn on lessons from the Greensill situation as we have strengthened our procedures, training, and guidance."

The calendar is the crack

The FRC's Conduct Committee decided to open the investigation on 15 June 2021. It was announced on 28 June 2021, then under the firm's former name, Saffery Champness LLP, which the FSDN records was changed on 4 September 2023. Settlement was agreed on 30 July 2026. The final notice is dated 24 August 2026. The public outcome followed on 16 November 2026.

The decision records a specific gap in the audit file. It contained no finished audit plan or equivalent document. The auditors had instead used sections of the firm's audit software and supplemented them with individual working papers.

Nothing in the FRC's decision says that anyone altered a working paper. The findings go to planning, evidence, scepticism and quality control.

A recorded fingerprint can tell a reviewer whether the copy in front of them matches the one recorded earlier. It does not say when a document was first created. The audit file still has to show what work was done, what evidence was obtained and how the auditor reached their conclusions.

What firms can do now. When a regulator opens an audit file years after the opinion was signed, the working papers are what remain. Partisan records a file's fingerprint without seeing or keeping the document, gives a dated receipt, and shows a file is unchanged since it was recorded. Try it on one PDF for £45 (credited against a Full-file job), or keep ongoing records across a firm's assurance, insolvency or investigation matters for £350 a month. partisangateway.com

Sources

Public sources only, as linked. Disclosure: I work on business development and communications for Partisan, which offers file fingerprint receipts for comparing copies, and the note on what firms can do now describes its paid service. Partisan supplied nothing else for this article. This article makes no allegations about any person or firm beyond the public FRC record, and it names no party to any private dispute. This piece is for general information and is not legal, audit or regulatory advice.

Sources