Unexplained Wealth Orders are no longer fit for purpose: the Criminal Finances Act 2017 and the 2022 reforms

Unexplained Wealth Orders in England and Wales: five orders in 2024 to 2025, late reports and six reforms. How the Criminal Finances Act 2017 and the Economic Crime (Transparency and Enforcement) Act 2022 shape the power.

Listen to this article

73 paragraphs

Charles Pycraft · November 2026 · London

Cover card: Unexplained Wealth Orders. Navy ground, a gold house outline with a question mark inside and an hourglass beside it. Labelled POCA 2002, Criminal Finances Act 2017, ECTEA 2022, small CP mark. By Charles Pycraft

This article is part of Offshore: the enabler chain. It sits in pillar 3: Why recovery fails, and follows Who pays when asset recovery fails in the reading order. Start with the series overview if you are new to the work.

Opinion. Updated on 17 November 2026.

The short version

An Unexplained Wealth Order (UWO) requires an explanation of how specified property was obtained. Parliament created the power in 2017 and widened it in 2022. The tool can work. The National Crime Agency (NCA) says two investigations in which it obtained UWOs led to settlements worth about £55 million, which the High Court approved on 12 November 2026.

The same record shows a power used a handful of times a year. The latest statutory report records five orders in England and Wales. The Serious Fraud Office first obtained one in 2025 and the Crown Prosecution Service followed in 2026, which leaves two of the five authorities with no public record of use. The reporting duty covers two numbers, and all three published reports appeared late. The fourth was due by mid-September 2026, and I could find no published copy as at 17 November. In my view, a power still this narrow in use and this thin in reporting is no longer fit for the purpose Parliament gave it.

What the law says: the Criminal Finances Act 2017 and the Economic Crime (Transparency and Enforcement) Act 2022

Sections 1 to 3 of the Criminal Finances Act 2017 inserted sections 362A to 362T into the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 (POCA). The power came into force in England and Wales on 31 January 2018.

The Economic Crime (Transparency and Enforcement) Act 2022, in force for these purposes from 15 May 2022, made four main changes to the order:

The same Act added section 362IA. The Secretary of State must publish two counts for each reporting year from 15 May to 14 May: applications to the High Court in England and Wales and orders it made. The publication deadline is four months from the end of the reporting period, and a copy must be laid before Parliament. Those two counts are all the report must contain.

What the record shows: how many UWOs have been made

The early years. A House of Lords written answer, HL4511 of 11 February 2025, counts operations rather than orders. It lists seven operations that obtained a UWO from 2018 to early 2025: one in 2018, three in 2019, none from 2020 to 2022, and one in each of 2023, 2024 and 2025. Its entries total £146.775 million in estimated assets secured and £22 million in estimated recovery orders. The answer records no prosecutions or convictions in the figures it supplies and explains that civil recovery requires neither.

In its judgment of 8 April 2020, [2020] EWHC 822 (Admin), the High Court discharged three UWOs and the related interim freezing orders. It found the NCA's assumptions about the source of funds unreliable and the statutory requirements unmet. The Home Office attributes part of the later rise to the "reduced risk of high costs" after the 2022 reforms.

The statutory reports. The three reports published so far (each covering 15 May to 14 May) show:

These counts follow each year's own report. The 2024 to 2025 commentary refers to two applications in its comparison with earlier years; the 2022 to 2023 report records one within its period and another before it began. The ministerial statement of 24 February 2026 calls five the highest annual number of applications since the power was introduced. It describes UWOs as intended for "particularly high value and complex cases" and says other powers are more appropriate in most cases. The 2023 to 2024 report adds that the five agencies are operationally independent and "cannot be tasked to use UWOs".

On my reading of section 362IA, each report was due by mid-September. All three appeared after that: by days, by about three months and by more than five months. The GOV.UK collection still listed three reports on 17 November 2026, two months after the fourth was due. I found no published fourth report or written parliamentary statement announcing its laying by that date. The Home Office's own asset recovery statistics say the report "will be published separately to the annual statistical bulletin every September".

The rise since 2025. Use is now growing. The SFO obtained its first UWO in January 2025, over a property of about £1.5 million connected with a concluded £100 million fraud prosecution, and secured £1.1 million after the property was sold. On 18 March 2026, the CPS obtained its first UWO and a separate interim order freezing 85 London properties worth more than £81 million. On 23 October 2026 it obtained its second UWO and a separate freeze covering assets worth about £50 million, with properties in England, France, Spain and Portugal. In both announcements, the CPS said the individuals had not been charged with or convicted of any criminal activity.

In a separate case, the High Court dismissed a challenge to an unexplained wealth order and interim freezing order obtained by the NCA in March 2026, [2026] EWHC 573 (Admin).

On 13 November 2026 the NCA announced two civil settlements approved by the High Court the day before. The agency linked both cases to one of Singapore's largest money laundering cases. It said one respondent agreed to surrender 75 per cent of his assets. In the other settlement, the NCA said it would sell the identified property and retain 75 per cent of the proceeds, plus £1.2 million in rental income.

The Home Office bulletin for England, Wales and Northern Ireland puts the value investigated under UWOs at £451.5 million in the year ending March 2026, up from £1.8 million. It records £431.7 million frozen under interim freezing orders, against zero the previous year. The Home Office warns that a UWO value is not a receipt: the bulletin reports civil recovery receipts separately, and those include cases that never involved a UWO (see Asset recovery is no longer fit for purpose).

I found no public record of a UWO obtained by HMRC or the FCA, which have held the power since January 2018, almost nine years.

Why this reading says "no longer fit for purpose"

The tool is not broken. When it is used, respondents must explain; a failure to comply without reasonable excuse brings a rebuttable presumption in later civil recovery; and some cases settle. The argued reading concerns how widely the power is used and what the public can learn about its outcomes.

The government's Anti-money laundering and asset recovery strategy 2026 to 2029, published on 15 September 2026, says the scale of money laundering "is widely thought to reach into the hundreds of billions", though it adds that only part is recoverable. Against that, the statutory reports count one to five applications a year. The Home Office's 2017 impact assessment modelled 20 cases a year after the first year, using a conservative average value of £100,000 per order. The published application counts are a quarter of that assumption or less, although some cases concern much larger sums. Use sits with the NCA, joined by the SFO in 2025 and the CPS in 2026. The tax authority and the main financial regulator are absent from the public record.

The reporting does not allow anyone outside the agencies to judge whether that is the right level. Section 362IA asks for two numbers. It does not ask which agency applied, how many cases were considered and set aside, how many orders were discharged, how many freezes ran to the 186-day limit, what costs were paid, or what each order led to. Three official series count differently: operations in HL4511, orders in the annual report, and value in the asset recovery statistics.

Time is the last gap. The 2026 strategy says proving criminality can be hard "especially where key evidence sits overseas in jurisdictions that will not cooperate". A request for evidence from another country may still be outstanding when the determination period ends; I found no official figure for how long such requests take in UWO cases. After timely compliance, section 362K then requires the court to discharge the interim freeze once the statutory 48-hour period passes without a qualifying application, such as one for a property freezing order with its own test, whatever the state of the request.

Who owns the fix

The Home Office leads UWO policy and prepares the statutory report. Action 44 of its joint strategy with HM Treasury schedules a Home Office consultation on asset recovery legislation for 2026/27. I found no public launch by 17 November 2026. The five authorities decide when to apply. The Secretary of State sets any NCA strategic priorities. Under section 2A, the Secretary of State can guide the NCA, the Attorney General the two Directors, and HM Treasury HMRC and the FCA. Parliament can change the statutory rules. The Home Affairs and Public Accounts Committees can scrutinise the delay. The National Audit Office lists its recovery study for winter 2026/27.

What should change

Property that cannot be explained should meet a question, and the answer, or the silence, should have a predictable result.

  1. Publish the overdue report, then report outcomes. Publish the 2025 to 2026 report now. Then give by agency the applications, orders, refusals, discharges, interim freezing orders and their values, extensions under section 362DA, costs paid, and outcomes in aggregate: civil recovery, settlement, no further action or ongoing. The Home Office can publish additional aggregate figures it holds and can lawfully disclose. Amending section 362IA would make the additional reporting a duty. Owner: the Home Office for publication and consultation, and Parliament for any amendment.
  2. Show the cases considered as well as the cases brought. Each of the five agencies should publish, once a year and in summary, how many cases it assessed for a UWO, how many it took forward and the main reasons for setting the others aside. The figures would show whether HMRC and the FCA considered applications and what informed their decisions. Owner: the five authorities for the figures and the Home Office for collation.
  3. Fund a standing multi-agency UWO team. Use the specialist investment in action 41 to support a proposed National Economic Crime Centre team that screens referrals against the statutory tests. The NCA's annual plan should set an aim for screening capacity and publish the number of referrals assessed. Each authority would decide which cases to take forward. Owner: the Home Office for funding and the NCA Director General for the annual plan, with the CPS, SFO, HMRC and FCA.
  4. Allow limited court extensions for overseas evidence. Allow the High Court to extend the determination period beyond 186 days, for up to 63 days at a time within a fixed statutory cap. On each application, the agency should show diligent pursuit of material evidence under a formal overseas request and that the continuing freeze is necessary and proportionate. Affected parties should be able to challenge it. Section 303Z37 already permits up to three years for a crypto wallet freeze where an overseas evidence request is outstanding. Owner: the Home Office for consultation and Parliament for legislation.
  5. Keep the 2022 costs rule and report against it. Keep section 362U. The report in fix 1 should give the number and value of adverse costs awards under the section, with the statutory grounds where recorded. Owner: the Home Office; Parliament.
  6. Update the settlement guidance and publish terms. Settlements avoid long litigation and can return money quickly. Paragraph 10 of the section 2A guidance says an authority may accept a reduced sum if reasonable and consistent with public confidence. It says nothing on victims, overseas states or publication. Ministers should add guidance on those, and agencies should publish a summary of each settlement where lawful, with its value and where the proceeds go. Owner: the Home Secretary, HM Treasury and the Attorney General for guidance in England and Wales, and each settling authority for publication.

About this piece

Public sources only, as linked. It makes no allegations about any person or firm. Court cases and agency releases are described as reported. An unexplained wealth order is an investigative step and makes no finding of wrongdoing, and respondents in open proceedings have not been found to hold the proceeds of crime. Holding property through companies or offshore is not itself unlawful. Opinion is marked as argued reading. This piece is not legal advice.

Previous: Who pays when asset recovery fails: the cost rules are no longer fit for purpose

Related: Asset recovery is no longer fit for purpose; Enabler liability is no longer fit for purpose; Overseas Territories beneficial ownership registers are no longer fit for purpose

Series overview: Offshore: the enabler chain

Sources

Sources