Back to Offshore & Investigations
Litigation funding after PACCAR is no longer fit for purpose: section 58AA, the 2013 Regulations and a promised Bill with no date
How PACCAR affects funding under section 58AA of the Courts and Legal Services Act 1990 and the Damages-Based Agreements Regulations 2013. Ministers pledged prospective reform in December 2025. No replacement Bill or date by 18 November 2026.
Listen to this article
84 paragraphs
Charles Pycraft · November 2026 · London
Part of Offshore: the enabler chain, pillar 3: Why recovery fails. It follows Cross-border civil enforcement is no longer fit for purpose in the reading order.
Opinion. Updated on 18 November 2026.
The short version
Third-party funding can let people who cannot afford complex fraud or trust claims bring them to court. On 26 July 2023 the Supreme Court held in R (PACCAR Inc and others) v Competition Appeal Tribunal [2023] UKSC 28 that agreements of the kind before it, which paid funders a percentage of damages recovered, were damages-based agreements. The court was told that this interpretation would likely make most third-party litigation funding agreements unenforceable under the law as it then stood.
The previous Conservative government introduced a short Bill in March 2024 to take litigation funding agreements out of the damages-based agreements rules. It fell when Parliament was dissolved. The Civil Justice Council recommended reversal in June 2025. On 17 December 2025 the government pledged prospective reversal and proportionate regulation. Eleven months later, there is still no replacement Bill, timetable or named legislative vehicle for that pledge.
In my view, a reform drafted by one government, recommended by the Civil Justice Council and promised by the next, then left waiting for "parliamentary time" while victims carry the cost of suing, is no longer fit for purpose.
What PACCAR decided: the Compensation Act 2006 and section 58AA
The case began with applications to bring collective claims in the Competition Appeal Tribunal over a truck cartel. The question was whether a funder that pays for a claim in return for a share of the damages provides "claims management services". The definition at issue came from section 4 of the Compensation Act 2006 and included financial services or assistance. Since 2019, section 58AA(7) has referred to section 419A of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000. By a majority of four to one, the Supreme Court held that the words should be read in their natural meaning, and that they covered the funding agreements.
That pulled percentage-based funding into section 58AA of the Courts and Legal Services Act 1990. A damages-based agreement that does not meet the conditions in section 58AA(4) and the Damages-Based Agreements Regulations 2013 is unenforceable. Under section 47C(8) of the Competition Act 1998, damages-based agreements remain unenforceable in opt-out collective proceedings before the Competition Appeal Tribunal. On 17 July 2026 the Department for Business and Trade proposed lifting that ban in a consultation specific to the tribunal.
How the market adapted, and what that left out
Funders in the linked appeals [2025] EWCA Civ 841 revised their agreements to calculate fees as multiples of their outlay or committed outlay. In July 2025 the Court of Appeal held that capping such a fee at the proceeds did not make the agreement a damages-based agreement. On 6 November 2025 the Supreme Court refused permission to appeal to Visa and, in one of the linked cases, Apple. Neither application raised an arguable point of law.
The judgment resolved this objection to the revised agreements in the linked cases. Unamended agreements that still calculate fees as a percentage of damages remain exposed, and funding challenges can arise at certification, before the tribunal decides the merits. In the House of Lords on 3 September 2026, a Conservative former minister put it plainly: "everyone agrees that the Supreme Court decision in PACCAR should be reversed by legislation. Until it is, satellite litigation will proliferate."
The Bill that fell, the report that followed, the promise that waits
- 19 March 2024. The Litigation Funding Agreements (Enforceability) Bill [HL] is introduced in the House of Lords. Its committee stage is on 29 April 2024. It falls when Parliament is dissolved for the July 2024 election.
- 2 June 2025. The Civil Justice Council publishes its final report, with 58 recommendations. Recommendation 1: legislation should make clear that litigation funding is not a damages-based agreement, "reverse the effect of PACCAR", and "have prospective and retrospective effect".
- 17 December 2025. The Courts minister tells Parliament in a written statement that the government will legislate "to clarify that LFAs are not Damages Based Agreements, with prospective effect", and will introduce "proportionate regulation". It adds: "We will introduce legislation when parliamentary time allows."
- 10 February 2026. Asked for a timeline, the minister answers: "We intend to make this change with prospective effect." No date is given.
- 13 May 2026. On the King's Speech, Osborne Clarke notes that litigation funding "was absent from the programme entirely".
- 3 September 2026. In a Lords exchange, the justice minister says the government is "working urgently to identify a new legislative vehicle". The same Conservative former minister, pointing to the 2024 Bill, tells the House that "the necessary legislation is ready and waiting". The minister says he cannot give a date.
- 15 September 2026. In a written answer, the minister says the government is "pursuing the earliest legislative vehicle".
- 9 November 2026. In a further written answer, the minister restates the December 2025 commitment to legislate "when Parliamentary time allows" and says the government will set out its plans on the wider recommendations "in due course".
- 14 October to 17 November 2026. The Ministry of Justice's Courts and Tribunals Bill reaches the Lords on 14 October. It covers criminal courts, tribunal leadership and section 1 of the Children Act 1989, and arrives without a litigation funding provision. Lords committee sits on 10 and 16 November with no funding amendment on the marshalled lists, and the report-stage running list to 17 November contains none either. Report stage is scheduled for 1 December.
I found no other Bill on the subject as at 18 November 2026.
The retrospective gap
The Civil Justice Council sought retrospective effect for agreements in ongoing and concluded claims, including cases where renegotiation may be impracticable. The government proposes prospective reform. In my reading, without a transitional provision covering older agreements, a claimant still relying on an unamended percentage-based agreement signed before 26 July 2023 could remain exposed to a PACCAR challenge. The position will depend on the Bill's wording.
Who pays while Parliament waits
The victim pays first. Under the agreements considered here, a funder's return comes from the proceeds if the claim succeeds. In my view, uncertainty about enforceability can make funding more expensive or harder to obtain. A claimant who cannot find another way to pay may have to abandon the claim.
The public pays next. In my reading, an ordinary civil claim to recover fraud losses falls outside the categories in Schedule 1 to the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012. Section 10 provides for exceptional case funding where its tests are met. What that costs victims and the public purse is set out in Who pays when asset recovery fails.
The people who caused the loss pay least. In my view, when a viable claim never reaches court because the claimant cannot fund it, those who designed or ran the structure escape a civil claim and the victim carries the loss.
The Crime Survey for England and Wales estimated 4.5 million fraud incidents in the year to June 2026, up 11 per cent on the previous year. The survey gives no estimate of how many incidents could support a civil claim or require litigation funding.
What the Civil Justice Council asked for beyond PACCAR
Beyond reversal, the report asked for:
- A regulator with teeth (recommendations 4 and 8): a formal statutory scheme replacing self-regulation, with the Lord Chancellor given the power to regulate funding by statutory instrument, including sanctions for funders who breach the rules.
- Capital adequacy and insurance (recommendation 10): ongoing, case-specific capital adequacy and after-the-event insurance against adverse costs, with safeguards against the insurer avoiding the policy, for non-commercial parties or collective or group proceedings.
- Anti-money laundering rules for funders (recommendation 11). In my reading, that matters for this series: a funder can be a route for money into a claim as well as out of one.
- Disclosure (recommendation 13): the fact of funding, the funder's name and "the ultimate source of the funding" to be disclosed to the court and the other side.
- A Consumer Duty (recommendation 17) for funders where the funded party is a consumer or a party to collective proceedings, a representative action or a group action.
- Data (recommendation 3): a Standing Committee on Litigation Funding to collect and monitor data on funding, with funders, law firms and HM Courts and Tribunals Service under a duty to supply it.
- An Access to Justice Fund (recommendation 57): the government "should consider" requiring "a small percentage of the profits from litigation funding" and from conditional and damages-based fee agreements to be paid into a fund for early legal advice and alternative dispute resolution.
The December statement said the government would consider the wider recommendations after implementing prospective reversal and proportionate regulation. The 9 November answer says it is already considering those recommendations, including litigation affordability, and will set out its plans in due course.
Why this reading says "no longer fit for purpose"
Agreement without action. The fix has been drafted once, recommended once and accepted once. The block, in the minister's own words in the Lords, is "people like me and other Ministers competing for legislative time". In my view, a reform with cross-party support and a ready text should not still be losing that competition more than three years after PACCAR.
Funding rests on case law, not the promised fix. The Court of Appeal settled how section 58AA applies to the fee formulas before it. In my view that leaves too much uncertainty for a market the justice minister told the Lords is "crucial for enabling ordinary people to access justice".
Missing data. The Civil Justice Council identified a data gap. I found no official series tracking funded claims, funding refusals, funder returns and claims abandoned for lack of funding. That makes the cost of delay harder to measure.
No route for the claims funders will not take. The Civil Justice Council did not recommend further work on a contingency legal aid fund, because no positive case for its viability was put to it. It did ask the government to consider other routes, including a class proceedings fund for low value claims, particularly mass or collective ones (recommendation 2) and an Access to Justice Fund (recommendation 57). In my view, victims with viable cross-border fraud or trust claims that commercial funders decline can still be left without a practical route to sue.
As Who pays when asset recovery fails argues, when the remedy for wrongdoing is priced beyond the people harmed, the cost stays with them.
Who owns the fix
The Ministry of Justice leads on reform and the government must find parliamentary time. The Civil Procedure Rule Committee makes civil procedure rules. The Secretary of State makes the Competition Appeal Tribunal's rules.
What should change in litigation funding
- Bring the short Bill back now. Reintroduce the 2024 text, or a close version, as a standalone Bill or as amendments to the next available Ministry of Justice Bill, with a published timetable. Owner: Ministry of Justice and Parliament.
- Protect existing agreements. Give the reversal retrospective effect, as the Civil Justice Council recommended. I would protect agreements made in good faith before PACCAR and preserve final decisions on their enforceability. Owner: Ministry of Justice.
- Regulate funders properly, including on money laundering. Implement recommendations 4, 8, 10, 11, 13 and 17. Give the Lord Chancellor power to regulate by statutory instrument, with sanctions, capital adequacy, insurance, anti-money laundering duties, funding-source disclosure and a Consumer Duty. Owner: Ministry of Justice, by statute and statutory instrument.
- Publish the numbers. Set up the Standing Committee on Litigation Funding and report yearly on funded claims, refusals, returns, adverse costs and claims dropped for lack of funding. Owner: Ministry of Justice and the Civil Procedure Rule Committee.
- Build a victims' route for claims funders will not take. Build on the Civil Justice Council's proposed Access to Justice Fund for early advice and dispute resolution. I would add a ring-fenced strand to the victims' recovery and litigation costs fund proposed in Who pays when asset recovery fails, drawing on a levy on funder profits and the companion piece's proposed share of asset recovery receipts and Economic Crime Levy revenue. Owner: Ministry of Justice, Home Office and HM Treasury.
- Make those who caused the loss carry the funding cost. Amend the civil procedure and Competition Appeal Tribunal rules to allow recovery of funding costs in exceptional cases, as the Civil Justice Council recommended (recommendation 41). I would start with suitable fraud and breach of trust cases. Owner: Civil Procedure Rule Committee and the Secretary of State for the tribunal rules.
What firms can do now. A funding challenge can turn on how the agreement and any amendments calculate the funder's fee. Partisan records a file's fingerprint without seeing or keeping the document, gives a dated receipt, and shows a file is unchanged since it was recorded. Try it on one PDF for £45 (credited towards a full job), or cover a whole firm's assurance, insolvency or investigation files for £350 a month. partisangateway.com
About this piece
Public sources only, as linked: the Supreme Court judgment, the Civil Justice Council's final report, the government's written statement and answers, Hansard, the Parliament bills database, legislation.gov.uk, the Office for National Statistics and published legal commentary. Disclosure: I work on business development and communications for Partisan, which offers file fingerprint receipts for comparing copies, and the note on what firms can do now describes its paid service. Partisan supplied nothing else for this article. It makes no allegations about any person, firm or funder, and it names no party to any private dispute. Readings of the statutes and judgments are marked as my reading; how a court applies them depends on the facts. Opinion is marked as argued reading. This piece is for general information and is not legal advice.
Previous: Cross-border civil enforcement is no longer fit for purpose
Related: Who pays when asset recovery fails: the cost rules are no longer fit for purpose; Enabler liability is no longer fit for purpose; The Swiss SRO layer, STEP, and the cost of fighting back
Series overview: Offshore: the enabler chain
Sources
- R (PACCAR Inc and others) v Competition Appeal Tribunal [2023] UKSC 28, 26 July 2023: supremecourt.uk/cases/uksc-2021-0078
- Compensation Act 2006, section 4 (as enacted): legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2006/29/section/4/enacted
- Financial Services and Markets Act 2000, section 419A: legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2000/8/section/419A
- Courts and Legal Services Act 1990, section 58AA: legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1990/41/section/58AA
- Damages-Based Agreements Regulations 2013: legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2013/609/contents
- Competition Act 1998, section 47C: legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1998/41/section/47C
- Court of Appeal, [2025] EWCA Civ 841, 4 July 2025: caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewca/civ/2025/841
- Supreme Court, permission to appeal refused 6 November 2025, UKSC/2025/0158 (Visa) and UKSC/2025/0159 (Apple): supremecourt.uk/cases/uksc-2025-0158 , supremecourt.uk/cases/uksc-2025-0159
- Department for Business and Trade, Swifter and Simpler Competition Redress, Regulatory Appeals and Competition Enforcement, consultation issued 17 July 2026 (paragraphs 30 to 45): gov.uk/government/consultations/swifter-and-simpler-competition-redress-regulatory-appeals-and-competition-enforcement
- Litigation Funding Agreements (Enforceability) Bill [HL], 2024, and its stages: bills.parliament.uk/bills/3702 , bills.parliament.uk/bills/3702/stages
- Courts and Tribunals Bill, Parliament bills database, and HL Bill 57 running list of amendments on report, to 17 November 2026: bills.parliament.uk/bills/4083 , bills.parliament.uk/publications/68795/documents/9072
- Civil Justice Council, Review of Litigation Funding: Final Report, 2 June 2025: judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/CJC-Review-of-Litigation-Funding-Final-Report.pdf
- Written statement HCWS1192, Third-Party Litigation Funding, 17 December 2025: questions-statements.parliament.uk/written-statements/detail/2025-12-17/hcws1192
- Written question 110730, answered 10 February 2026: questions-statements.parliament.uk/written-questions/detail/2026-02-04/110730
- Written question 901382, tabled 9 September 2026, answered 15 September 2026: questions-statements.parliament.uk/written-questions/detail/2026-09-09/901382
- Written question 39663, answered 9 November 2026: questions-statements.parliament.uk/written-questions/detail/2026-10-30/39663
- Hansard (Lords), Opt-out Collective Court Actions and Connected Litigation Funding, 3 September 2026: hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2026-09-03/debates/BC0898E1-F7C4-47A6-8754-CC683893EF84/Opt-OutCollectiveCourtActionsAndConnectedLitigationFunding
- Osborne Clarke, King's Speech prolongs uncertainty on reform of litigation funding: osborneclarke.com/insights/kings-speech-prolongs-uncertainty-reform-litigation-funding-england-and-wales
- Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012, section 10 and Schedule 1: legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2012/10/section/10 , legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2012/10/schedule/1
- Office for National Statistics, Crime in England and Wales: year ending June 2026: ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/crimeandjustice/bulletins/crimeinenglandandwales/yearendingjune2026
Sources
- https://www.supremecourt.uk/cases/uksc-2021-0078
- https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2006/29/section/4/enacted
- https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2000/8/section/419A
- https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1990/41/section/58AA
- https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2013/609/contents
- https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1998/41/section/47C
- https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewca/civ/2025/841
- https://www.supremecourt.uk/cases/uksc-2025-0158
- https://www.supremecourt.uk/cases/uksc-2025-0159
- https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/swifter-and-simpler-competition-redress-regulatory-appeals-and-competition-enforcement
- https://bills.parliament.uk/bills/3702
- https://bills.parliament.uk/bills/3702/stages
- https://bills.parliament.uk/bills/4083
- https://bills.parliament.uk/publications/68795/documents/9072
- https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/CJC-Review-of-Litigation-Funding-Final-Report.pdf
- https://questions-statements.parliament.uk/written-statements/detail/2025-12-17/hcws1192
- https://questions-statements.parliament.uk/written-questions/detail/2026-02-04/110730
- https://questions-statements.parliament.uk/written-questions/detail/2026-09-09/901382
- https://questions-statements.parliament.uk/written-questions/detail/2026-10-30/39663
- https://hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2026-09-03/debates/BC0898E1-F7C4-47A6-8754-CC683893EF84/Opt-OutCollectiveCourtActionsAndConnectedLitigationFunding
- https://www.osborneclarke.com/insights/kings-speech-prolongs-uncertainty-reform-litigation-funding-england-and-wales
- https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2012/10/section/10
- https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2012/10/schedule/1
- https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/crimeandjustice/bulletins/crimeinenglandandwales/yearendingjune2026