Back to Offshore & Investigations

Cross-border civil enforcement is no longer fit for purpose: the Lugano Convention 2007, Hague 2005 and Hague 2019 after Brexit

The EU blocked UK accession to the Lugano Convention in 2021, withholding its consent. Hague 2019 has applied to the UK since 1 July 2025, but Switzerland is outside it. Six fixes for cross-border enforcement.

Listen to this article

83 paragraphs

Charles Pycraft · November 2026 · London

Cover card: judgments that stop at the border. Navy ground, a bridge with its middle span missing and a gold judgment sheet halted at the gap. Labelled Lugano 2007, Hague 2005, Hague 2019, small CP mark. By Charles Pycraft

Part of Offshore: the enabler chain, pillar 3: Why recovery fails. It follows Unexplained Wealth Orders are no longer fit for purpose in the reading order.

Opinion. Updated on 18 November 2026.

The short version

Winning in an English court is half the job if the money has gone abroad. Until the end of 2020, a judgment from a UK court could travel to Switzerland, Norway and Iceland under the Lugano Convention 2007 with very limited grounds for refusal. The UK applied to rejoin in its own right on 8 April 2020. Switzerland, Iceland and Norway consented. The European Union did not, and accession needs every party's consent.

In its place the UK now relies on two Hague Conventions. Hague 2005 covers only exclusive choice-of-court clauses. Hague 2019, in force for the UK since 1 July 2025, is wider, but Switzerland has not joined it. Outside the treaty routes, Swiss recognition generally depends on the Swiss Federal Act on Private International Law (PILA). If recognition fails, the claimant may have to sue again in Switzerland.

In my view, a system that can make a claimant who has already won in court win again, and pay again, to reach the money is no longer fit for purpose.

What changed on 1 January 2021: the Lugano Convention 2007 and the EU's refusal

Lugano mirrors the EU's Brussels rules for three European Free Trade Association states. Under Article 38, a judgment enforceable where it was given is enforced in another Lugano state once declared enforceable there. Article 32 defines "judgment" broadly, including any "order". The UK took part through EU membership and remained covered during the Brexit transition. The Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments (Amendment) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019 ended Lugano's domestic effect at 11pm on 31 December 2020, subject to savings for earlier proceedings and certain other pre-transition-end instruments and settlements.

The UK's application reached the depositary, the Swiss Federal Council, on 8 April 2020. Article 72(3) requires unanimous agreement. The Swiss Federal Office of Justice records Swiss consent on 11 September 2020, Icelandic consent on 26 February 2021 and Norwegian consent on 30 March 2021.

On 4 May 2021 the European Commission advised against. Its assessment, COM(2021) 222, said that "the Lugano Convention is a flanking measure of the internal market" and that the UK "is a third country without a special link to the internal market". In a note verbale dated 22 June 2021 and received by the depositary on 28 June, the Commission, acting for the EU, said the EU "is not in a position to give its consent", as the Swiss Federal Office of Justice also records. The depositary notified the parties on 1 July 2021.

Five years on, the application remains pending. On 20 January 2026 the Ministry of Justice told Parliament in a written answer that the application "remains pending" because of the EU's June 2021 note verbale, and cited UK ratification of Hague 2019 as evidence of continued cooperation. In May 2024 the House of Lords International Agreements Committee had regretted "the EU's decision to block the UK's accession" and urged the government to resume its efforts. In written evidence to the Business and Trade Committee in May 2026, the Law Society said the UK-EU reset "has so far been unable to produce any legally binding commitment" in areas including civil judicial cooperation.

Hague 2005 and Hague 2019: what the UK has instead

The UK deposited its own accession to Hague 2005 on 28 September 2020, effective in its own right from 1 January 2021, and the Private International Law (Implementation of Agreements) Act 2020 gave it the force of law. Hague 2005 generally requires an exclusive choice-of-court agreement recorded in writing or another accessible form (Articles 1 and 3). It excludes consumer and employment agreements and leaves interim measures of protection outside its scope.

Hague 2019 is the bigger step. The UK signed on 12 January 2024, ratified on 27 June 2024, and it entered into force for the UK on 1 July 2025, across England and Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland, through the Recognition and Enforcement of Judgments (2019 Hague Convention etc.) Regulations 2024 (SI 2024/713). Judgments are registered in the High Court, or the Court of Session in Scotland, under the new section 4C of the Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act 1982.

Its limits matter:

The Ministry of Justice knew the limits. In its November 2023 response to the consultation, it recorded that many responses called Lugano "the preferred framework", recognised respondents' concerns, raised for serious injury victims, that the Convention "excludes recognition and enforcement of interim measures", and acknowledged "the limitations presented by other exclusions from scope". It concluded that these limits "do not outweigh the many benefits of joining Hague 2019". The explanatory memorandum to SI 2024/713 expected the instrument to "be beneficial for businesses" but said "it is not possible to quantify the cost and benefits".

Switzerland: Hague 2005 since 2025, the Swiss PILA for everything else

Hague 2005 has applied to Switzerland since 1 January 2025, after it deposited its accession on 18 September 2024. It also made a declaration under Article 22 to recognise judgments given under non-exclusive clauses, but that works only between states that have both made it, and the HCCH status table shows no Article 22 declaration by the UK. Under Article 16, the clause must have been agreed after the Convention entered into force for the state of the chosen court, and the proceedings started after it entered into force for the state of the court seised. For a clause choosing Swiss courts, Swiss counsel at Bär & Karrer advise agreeing it after 1 January 2025; for a clause choosing UK courts, the UK date applies. Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer also treats the chosen state's date as the test for the clause. That helps banks and traders with an exclusive clause. A fraud victim rarely has a jurisdiction clause with the other side.

Outside Hague 2005 and Lugano's transitional cases, Swiss recognition generally falls under the PILA. Article 25 requires jurisdiction in the Swiss sense, a decision that is final or "no longer subject to any ordinary appeal", and no Article 27 ground for refusal. Lugano required enforceability in the state where the judgment was given and a Swiss declaration of enforceability, subject to limited refusal grounds. Article 26 includes domicile as a fallback, a valid jurisdiction agreement and an unreserved defence on the merits.

For claims under the law of obligations, Article 149 recognises a tort judgment given where the act or result occurred only where "the defendant was not domiciled in Switzerland". My reading of Articles 25, 26 and 149 is that an English tort judgment against a Swiss-domiciled defendant who did not appear may fail the Swiss jurisdiction test if it rests only on the place of the act or harm. The claimant may then have to sue in Switzerland. Article 149e gives trust judgments separate routes: a validly designated court, the state of the defendant's domicile, habitual residence or establishment, the state of the trust's seat, or the state whose law governs the trust. It also covers a judgment recognised at the trust's seat if the defendant was domiciled outside Switzerland, and has a separate rule for certain securities claims.

The old statutes: the 1920 Act, the 1933 Act and the common law

Coming into the UK, a judgment from a country with no treaty link meets old statutes or the common law. The Administration of Justice Act 1920 covers superior courts in parts of the Commonwealth: registration is discretionary and must be sought within twelve months unless the court allows longer. The Foreign Judgments (Reciprocal Enforcement) Act 1933 covers money judgments that are "final and conclusive", from courts listed by Order in Council. The orders listed on legislation.gov.uk include Norway, Israel, Canada, Australia and the Crown Dependencies. I found none for Switzerland.

Outside an applicable registration regime, an eligible final and conclusive foreign money judgment can support a fresh English debt claim. Ashurst Perkins Coie explains that the creditor can seek summary judgment. The foreign court must have jurisdiction under English recognition rules, for example through the defendant's presence or submission. For Swiss money judgments, this is the usual English route outside Hague 2005 and Lugano's transitional cases. In the other direction, the Swiss fallback is the PILA.

Norway shows what an existing treaty made possible. The agreement signed in Oslo on 13 October 2020 kept the amended 1961 judgments convention in force, implemented under the 1933 Act by the Reciprocal Enforcement of Foreign Judgments (Norway) (Amendment) (England and Wales and Northern Ireland) Order 2020 and a separate Scottish order. The UK and Switzerland had no equivalent bilateral judgments treaty to fall back on.

Who pays when a judgment does not travel

The claimant pays first. In England and Wales, on the July 2026 fee list, the issue fee for a money claim is £455 for a claim above £5,000 up to £10,000, 5 per cent of the claim above £10,000 up to £200,000, and £10,000 above £200,000. An application to register a judgment costs £82. A claimant may also need lawyers in both countries. Since 1 January 2025 the Swiss Civil Procedure Code lets a court demand an advance of up to half the expected court costs, and the full amount in some proceedings. Article 99 lets a defendant ask for security for party costs from a claimant with no Swiss residence, subject to exceptions.

Legal aid rarely helps: civil legal aid in England and Wales covers the matters listed in Schedule 1 to the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012, plus exceptional cases under section 10. An ordinary claim to recover money lost to a fraud is not on that list.

The Crime Survey for England and Wales estimated 4.5 million fraud incidents in the year to June 2026, up 11 per cent.

The Law Society's May 2026 evidence said enforcing judgments between the UK and the EU is "more complex and costly" than it used to be. That is "not so much a barrier for large companies, wealthy clients and their legal advisers", it said, but "an access to justice issue" for "families, consumers and small to medium enterprises that cannot afford to litigate their matters, multiple times in multiple courts". When claimants give up, the public carries part of the cost, as the earlier piece on who pays when asset recovery fails sets out.

Why this reading says "no longer fit for purpose"

The gap falls where the wealth is managed. Switzerland is a centre for cross-border wealth management, and the series has shown how far FINMA's reach stops at the border. In my view, that makes a dependable route for enforcing English judgments there especially important. The PILA limits recognition where an English tort judgment against a Swiss-domiciled defendant rests only on the place of the act or harm.

A bilateral treaty for financial services, none for judgments. The UK-Swiss Berne Financial Services Agreement took effect on 1 January 2026. It covers specified services, including investment services from eligible Swiss firms to qualifying UK clients and certain insurance from eligible UK insurers to large Swiss businesses. Its first Joint Committee met in London on 4 November 2026; the joint statement does not mention civil judgments. A fraud judgment outside Hague 2005 and Lugano's transitional rules still depends on domestic recognition law between the two countries.

Freezing orders stop at the frontier. Both Hague Conventions leave interim protective measures outside their recognition and enforcement rules. A claimant who fears assets will move may need to seek local relief quickly.

No published count. I found no published official series breaking down UK registrations of foreign judgments by legal route, including Hague 2019 registrations under the 1982 Act since July 2025, or counting UK judgments enforced in Switzerland. The Ministry of Justice's guidance for legal professionals on cross-border cases was first published on 31 December 2020 and, according to GOV.UK's record of changes, has not been updated since. It does not mention Hague 2019. The Civil Justice Council's April 2025 report on enforcement expressly left out "enforcement of judgments in other jurisdictions" and recommended further work on it. Its 2025-26 annual report lists follow-up work on domestic enforcement but no project on enforcement abroad.

Pending is not a policy. The Ministry of Justice cites Hague 2019 as evidence of cooperation. In my view, an application pending since April 2020 still needs a timetable.

Who owns the fix

The Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office (FCDO) and the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) should lead the UK work. For UK-wide implementation under section 2 of the 2020 Act, the Secretary of State can make regulations with the consent of the Scottish Ministers and a Northern Ireland department for devolved provision. First implementation by UK ministerial regulations requires approval by both Houses. That power was due to lapse in December 2025; the Private International Law (Implementation of Agreements) Act 2020 (Extension of Operative Period) Regulations 2025 (SI 2025/1201) extended it to the end of 12 December 2030. Parliament's Justice Committee and the Lords International Agreements Committee can ask for a timetable.

What should change in cross-border civil enforcement

In my view, winning in court should end the fight, not start a second one abroad.

  1. Keep a standing request to rejoin Lugano. Raise the April 2020 application at every UK-EU summit and in the Trade and Cooperation Agreement review, and report to Parliament yearly on its status and the EU's stated reasons. Owner: FCDO and MoJ.
  2. Negotiate a UK-Switzerland treaty on civil judgments. Cover money judgments in non-contractual claims, including fraud, against defendants domiciled in either country; protective orders made after the defendant has been heard; and judgments on trust claims, including claims against trustees. Use the 2020 Norway agreement as a precedent and go beyond the 1933 Act's final-money-judgment route. Set a target date for signature and make implementing regulations under section 2 of the 2020 Act by 12 December 2030, within the current operative period. Owner: FCDO and MoJ, with the devolved administrations and the relevant Swiss authorities, including the Federal Office of Justice.
  3. Ask Switzerland, Norway and Iceland to join Hague 2019, alongside fix 2, not instead of it. Owner: FCDO and MoJ.
  4. Publish the numbers. Report yearly the applications to register foreign judgments under each regime, outcomes and time taken, and certificates issued for UK judgments to be enforced abroad. Owner: MoJ and HM Courts and Tribunals Service, with their Scottish and Northern Irish counterparts for UK-wide figures.
  5. Commission the work the Civil Justice Council asked for. Review enforcement abroad, including whether the 1920 and 1933 Acts and the common-law debt route still fit, and update the 2020 GOV.UK guidance. Owner: MoJ, with the Civil Justice Council and the Law Commission.
  6. Lower the cost for individuals who have already won. In England and Wales, waive High Court registration, enforcement and overseas certificate fees for individuals enforcing judgments arising from fraud. Consider adding legal aid for English and Welsh advice and assistance on overseas enforcement by order under section 9(2) of the 2012 Act. Make express provision under section 32 if the scheme is to cover foreign-law services. Owner: MoJ, with Treasury consent for fee changes and delivery by HM Courts and Tribunals Service and the Legal Aid Agency.

What firms can do now. If a claimant has to bring the underlying claim again abroad, they may need to put some of the same documents before the second court. Partisan records a file's fingerprint without seeing or keeping the document, gives a dated receipt, and shows a file is unchanged since it was recorded. Try it on one PDF for £45 (credited towards a full job), or cover a whole firm's assurance, insolvency or investigation files for £350 a month. partisangateway.com

About this piece

Public sources only, as linked. Disclosure: I work on business development and communications for Partisan, which offers file fingerprint receipts for comparing copies, and the note on what firms can do now describes its paid service. Partisan supplied nothing else for this article. It makes no allegations about any person or firm, and it names no party to any private dispute. Readings of the Hague Conventions and the Swiss PILA are marked as my reading; how a court applies them depends on the facts. Opinion is marked as argued reading. This piece is for general information and is not legal advice.

Previous: Unexplained Wealth Orders are no longer fit for purpose: the Criminal Finances Act 2017 and the 2022 reforms

Related: Who pays when asset recovery fails: the cost rules are no longer fit for purpose; When FINMA's reach stops at the border; Asset recovery is no longer fit for purpose

Series overview: Offshore: the enabler chain

Sources

Sources