Back to Offshore & Investigations

Insolvency office-holder tracing is no longer fit for purpose: section 236, the Cross-Border Insolvency Regulations 2006 and the empty estate

Insolvency Act 1986 tracing powers meet empty estates. The Insolvency Service reported a £14.9m fee deficit in 2025-26. The Cross-Border Insolvency Regulations 2006 still lack the proposed route for recognising foreign insolvency judgments.

Listen to this article

81 paragraphs

Charles Pycraft · November 2026 · London

Cover image: an open, empty strongbox under a gold magnifying glass, with a trail of gold coins leading away to the edge of the frame. Navy ground, motif only, no text. By Charles Pycraft

Part of Offshore: the enabler chain, pillar 3: Why recovery fails. It follows Litigation funding is no longer fit for purpose in the reading order.

Opinion. Updated on 19 November 2026.

The short version

In England and Wales, a liquidator can use section 236 of the Insolvency Act 1986 to ask the court to summon witnesses and order production of company records. The court can issue an arrest warrant if a person fails to appear without reasonable excuse or there are reasonable grounds to believe they have absconded or are about to abscond to avoid appearing. Other provisions can unwind transfers made to put assets beyond creditors' reach.

The powers are strong. The money to use them often is not. An empty estate may be unable to pay for tracing. The Insolvency Service reported a £14.9 million deficit on services subject to insolvency fees in 2025-26. In July 2023 the government backed partial implementation of the UNCITRAL judgments Model Law, subject to further work. Its latest annual report records targeted stakeholder engagement in early 2026.

In my view, a tracing regime that is least effective where creditors need it most is no longer fit for purpose.

The toolkit: sections 236 and 237 of the Insolvency Act 1986

Section 236 applies in liquidation and administration. After a winding-up order in England and Wales, the Official Receiver can apply whether or not they are the liquidator. The court may summon any officer; any person "known or suspected to have in his possession any property of the company or supposed to be indebted to the company"; and any person it thinks capable of giving information about the company's "promotion, formation, business, dealings, affairs or property". In my reading, that last group can reach bankers, accountants, formation agents and other advisers who never sat on the board.

Section 237 turns information into recovery: the court may order a person holding company property to deliver it, or a debtor to pay. In my reading, section 236 can get documents faster than ordinary disclosure because the office-holder can apply before issuing a substantive claim against the witness.

Unwinding the transfers: sections 238, 239 and 423

In my reading, section 423 is particularly useful for an offshore transfer at an undervalue made to put assets beyond a creditor's reach. Ordinary limitation rules can still apply.

Following the people: sections 212 and 213

In a winding-up, section 212 gives the Official Receiver, liquidator, creditors and contributories a summary route to seek repayment or compensation from officers and others within the section. A contributory needs the court's leave, as does an applicant proceeding against a former liquidator after release. Under section 213, the liquidator can seek a contribution from anyone knowingly party to carrying on the company's business with intent to defraud creditors or for another fraudulent purpose.

These are the routes most able to reach an enabler who helped move value out of reach. In my view, the test of the system is whether they are used against those people, and each needs evidence and a funded claim.

The money problem: Official Receiver resourcing in 2025-26

The Insolvency Service Annual Report and Accounts 2025-26, published on 14 July 2026 (HC 395), shows more work on a deficit.

The report describes "a structural shortfall" and a new project for 2026-27 on "the remaining Official Receiver Services deficit". In my reading, this model rewards the case with assets in plain sight and penalises the one where they have gone. A company emptied before the petition yields the least fee income and needs the most tracing.

Enforcement outcomes 2025-26: no published total for overseas recovery

The Insolvency Service's enforcement outcomes for 2025-26, updated on 19 October 2026, record 1,158 director disqualifications (the annual report, published in July, gave 1,153), 81 defendants convicted, confiscation orders of £1,901,579, 125 civil compensation orders and undertakings worth £4,548,018, and 52 companies wound up in the public interest. Of 1,044 disqualifications under section 6 of the Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986, 773 recorded at least one allegation of COVID-19 financial support scheme abuse.

The Companies House Annual Report and Accounts 2025-26 adds the pipeline: 231 referrals to the Insolvency Service, 169 of them to its new Intelligence Cell; Companies House says the referrals resulted in "14 investigations into unlawful activity and 5 companies being wound up by the High Court in the public interest". The same report says investigators found that more than 11,000 companies had been registered without proper checks and that many had no real UK presence.

Compensation of about £4.5 million across 125 outcomes averages roughly £36,000 each. I found no published official series on section 236 applications, section 423 claims, assets identified abroad or sums recovered from outside the UK by office-holders. In my view, a system that does not count overseas recovery cannot show that it happens.

Fees that pay for enforcement: the Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act 2023

Parliament has built part of the answer. The Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act 2023 inserted subsection (3A) into section 1063 of the Companies Act 2006. Companies House fees may now reflect the cost of Insolvency Service work on "the detection, investigation or prosecution of offences, or the recovery of the proceeds of crime", and of Insolvency Act 1986 functions so far as they relate to companies and other firms.

Higher fees took effect in February 2026, and the Insolvency Service says its enforcement work moved to "a sustainable financial basis". Companies House reports an £11.7 million increase in spending on that work. It also reports that the Insolvency Service underspent by £4.1 million "due to slower workforce growth and lower legal costs".

In my view, that is the gap in one paragraph. Companies House fees already help fund enforcement. The published accounts identify no allocation for tracing in empty estates, and the Insolvency Service reports a deficit on services subject to insolvency fees. A dedicated allocation would need departmental and Treasury agreement. Under section 1063(6), registrar fees go to the Consolidated Fund.

Across borders: the 2006 Regulations, section 426 and a 2023 plan

The Cross-Border Insolvency Regulations 2006. Regulation 2 gives the UNCITRAL Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency the force of law in Great Britain. A foreign office-holder can seek recognition and relief here, including the examination of witnesses about the debtor's assets. Whether a UK liquidator gets the same help abroad depends on the other country's law.

Section 426. Under section 426(4), UK insolvency courts "shall assist" the courts of the Channel Islands, the Isle of Man and any designated "relevant country or territory". The designations sit in orders of 1986, 1996 and 1998. I found no later order. The duty binds UK courts; it does not bind a foreign court to help a UK office-holder.

The judgments Model Law. UNCITRAL adopted its Model Law on Recognition and Enforcement of Insolvency-Related Judgments in 2018. It covers judgments that arise from insolvency, such as orders setting aside transfers. The Insolvency Service consulted in 2022 on adopting only its Article X, which would add judgments to the relief available under the 2006 Regulations. On 10 July 2023 the government backed Article X in principle and said it would do further work on legal certainty before proceeding. The Private International Law (Implementation of Agreements) Act 2020 provides the power to implement it by statutory instrument. The current power runs until 12 December 2030.

The 2025-26 annual report records targeted engagement in early 2026 on a rule dating from 1890 about when foreign insolvency proceedings can affect contractual debts. On 19 November 2026, Schedule 1 to the 2006 Regulations still lacked the proposed Article X route. In my view, the UK cannot credibly press other jurisdictions to help its office-holders while its own 2023 plan on judgments stays unmet.

Who carries the cost when tracing fails

Unsecured creditors pay first. Tracing costs paid from the estate reduce what unsecured creditors can receive. An empty estate may leave a claim dependent on outside funding or the sale of an assignable claim.

The taxpayer pays twice. Where the relevant date is on or after 1 December 2020, section 98 of the Finance Act 2020 makes certain HMRC debts, including VAT and tax deducted from employees' pay, secondary preferential debts. In my reading, HMRC can be a significant creditor in these cases, so a shortfall can leave tax unpaid. The Department for Business and Trade met the Insolvency Service's £14.9 million deficit on services subject to insolvency fees.

Honest companies pay through fees. Companies House fees help fund Insolvency Service enforcement under the framework in section 1063(3A).

Those who caused the loss may pay least. Section 246ZD allows office-holders to assign claims under sections 213, 238 and 239, among others. Its list omits sections 423 and 212. A liquidator can sell the company's own claims against directors under Schedule 4. A buyer needs separate standing to use section 212. In my reading, the more pressing gap is an express power to assign an office-holder's section 423 claim. See Litigation funding after the 2023 ruling, Who pays when asset recovery fails, Asset recovery is no longer fit for purpose and Unexplained Wealth Orders are no longer fit for purpose.

The Corporate Civil Enforcement Reforms consultation, 2026

On 25 March 2026 the Insolvency Service opened Corporate Civil Enforcement Reforms, with 11 options. The options include shifting the burden to a connected party to show that a deal challenged as an undervalue in the two years before insolvency was fair, presuming insolvency at the time of or as a result of a connected-party preference, expressly bringing shadow directors within section 212 and widening investigators' information powers. The consultation closed on 22 June with 37 responses. On 22 October the government told Parliament it was considering them. The published timetable still gives spring 2027 for the response. Separately, reforms from the Future of Insolvency Regulation response are, the annual report says, "ready to legislate once a suitable Bill is available".

In my view, the proposals are sensible but stop at the border and at the estate account. None, as published, funds tracing where nothing is left to pay for it.

Who owns the fix

The Insolvency Service and the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade, which replaced the Department for Business and Trade on 9 November 2026, own the Official Receiver's funding and the 2026 consultation. HM Treasury sets the spending framework. The Secretary of State, through the same department, sets Companies House fees by regulations under section 1063. The courts apply sections 236 and 426. The Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office leads on relations with the Overseas Territories and other jurisdictions where traced value may sit.

What should change in insolvency office-holder tracing

  1. Create a ring-fenced Official Receiver tracing fund. Set aside a published share of the section 1063(3A) fee uplift for tracing in estates too poor to fund it, used whenever a public interest winding-up, disqualification or Official Receiver file shows value leaving the UK. Owner: Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade, HM Treasury and Companies House.
  2. Make those who caused the loss repay the tracing cost. Treat tracing costs as a first charge on sums recovered from directors, connected parties or those found knowingly party under section 213, and allow them to be added to compensation orders under section 15A of the Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986. Owner: Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade, in the consultation response.
  3. Widen the assignment power. Give office-holders an express power to assign their section 423 rights and give buyers of company claims standing to use the summary procedure in section 212. Owner: Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade, by legislation.
  4. Implement the judgments Model Law with a date. Lay the statutory instrument under the 2020 Act, starting with the Article X route into the 2006 Regulations proposed in the 2022 consultation, and work with the Overseas Territories and Crown Dependencies on matching rules. Owner: Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade and the Insolvency Service, with the Ministry of Justice, FCDO and devolved administrations where relevant.
  5. Count the money. Publish yearly figures for section 236 applications, section 423 and section 213 claims, assets identified abroad and sums recovered from outside the UK. Owner: Insolvency Service.
  6. Legislate what is ready. Put the Future of Insolvency Regulation reforms and the 2026 measures on shadow directors and connected-party transactions into the next suitable Bill. Owner: Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade and Parliament.

What firms can do now. Section 236 can put a company's books, papers and other records in an office-holder's hands, and a claim brought later may rely on those copies. Partisan records a file's fingerprint without seeing or keeping the document, gives a dated receipt, and shows a file is unchanged since it was recorded. Try it on one PDF for £45 (credited towards a full job), or cover a whole firm's assurance, insolvency or investigation files for £350 a month. partisangateway.com

About this piece

Public sources only, as linked: legislation.gov.uk, the Insolvency Service and Companies House annual reports and accounts for 2025-26, Insolvency Service enforcement data, government consultations on gov.uk, and UNCITRAL. Disclosure: I work on business development and communications for Partisan, which offers file fingerprint receipts for comparing copies, and the note on what firms can do now describes its paid service. Partisan supplied nothing else for this article. It makes no allegations about any person or firm, describes official machinery by category only, and names no party to any private dispute or insolvency. Readings of the statutes are marked as my reading; how a court applies them depends on the facts. Opinion is marked as argued reading. This piece is for general information and is not legal advice.

Previous: Litigation funding is no longer fit for purpose

Related: Who pays when asset recovery fails: the cost rules are no longer fit for purpose; Asset recovery is no longer fit for purpose; Unexplained Wealth Orders are no longer fit for purpose; Enabler liability is no longer fit for purpose

Series overview: Offshore: the enabler chain

Sources

Sources